Tech IT Easy

November 25, 2006

Racism & Antisemitism in Paris’s major soccer stadium

Filed under: Entertainment, Europe, Friends, Public policy, Security, user-generated content — Jeremy Fain @ 20:09

Sorry, no real connection with information technology, but since the focus of this blog is pretty international, I’d like to take advantage of the situation to let you know what happens here in France this week. I know it harms the reputation of the city I was born and live in, but I believe public criticism is well-deserved. Tourists coming to beautiful Paris ought to know what to expect if going to the stadium. Actually, let’s say the connection with IT is that blogging allows one to display a viewpoint instantly becoming available to all. In other words, the epitome of democracy…

I recently told you how bullish I was when taking a look at the entrepreneurial landscape in France: great people, great technologies, cash available for new venture initiatives, international ambitions, and so on and so forth.

Now, here’s the dark side of the force. The day before yesterday, I went with many friends, including girls, kids, parents, etc. to watch a football game in the Paris stadium Parc des Princes. I wasn’t, unlike some of my mates, so happy about the outcome (Paris lost), and I would bet laughed at by my Tel Aviv friends for a while (I spent 5 months in Tel Aviv launching a start-up last year). Worse: going out of the stadium, we found ourselves in the middle of a hooligan gang looking for Jews to kick some ass. We could hear them shouting: “Where are you Jews? Where are you Schlomos?” (“Ils sont où les Feujs? Ils sont où les Schlomos?”). Allright, I was used to it and all sorts of racism (actually occurring more often against Muslims & black people – but wait, story not over) since, although I hadn’t been at the stadium in a while, maybe 2 years, I had had a full ‘Auteuil’ supporter membership from 1997 to 2002 – going during this time period at almost every game of Paris Saint-Germain, the Paris-based soccer club.

Some – pretty scary, I saw them – hooligans, part of a group of ’supporters’ called Boulogne Boys, finally found a lone (they wouldn’t attack a group you understand) Jewish boy (23), and started to run after him. An undercover cop ran too, to protect him. But it happened that this policeman was black, so, can you imagine how excited the neo-nazis became, chasing a Jew and a Black? The press mentions that 150 skin-heads started kicking them two, and I heard one could survive not more than 2 minutes when on the ground and kicked in the head. So, the policeman took out his gun and shot twice, killing a young hooligan, wounding another one. It was him or the other guy. He did his best and was brave enough to avoid showing the gun earlier, but eventually had to do so.

Now what? Paris Saint-Germain’s Chairman, Mr. Alain Cayzac, a guy I used to respect most, wrote an apologizing letter (in French) to all supporters including the hooligans, not mentioning racism, not mentioning anti-semitism, not striking the slightest, smallest stance against racial issues in stadiums. Same business and shame when it comes to the coach. I thought the Boulogne Boys were an epiphenomenon that couldn’t be controlled, I discovered the Boulogne Boys were not actually out of control, but rather that nobody ever tried to take control, to eradicate stadiums of such evil people. I don’t give a damn of this skin-head’s life, it has no value. There were many, many kids (see picture below) in the stadium, many families. It could’ve been a lot worse.

I had a nice time at Parc des Princes, chit-chatting football with friends of all ages, watching the game, drinking a beer, etc. A long-time football-lover and supporter of Paris Saint-Germain, even when it played against an Israeli team, I was pretty sad of the result at first. Thinking twice, I don’t know why I would support a team managed by people implicitly supporting racism through avoiding the fight.

13 Comments »

  1. On the “PSG-Hapoel” case

    I planned to write a long post about the schocking event that took place after the football game in Paris opposing Hapoel Tel Aviv and Paris Saint Germain. But i read this morning this testimony by Jeremy Fain, that was

    Trackback by MYBLOG by Ouriel — November 26, 2006 @ 09:36

  2. That’s crazy. Compare it to here in Australia where you now can’t even take a bottle of water into a stadium for fear of terrorism.

    Comment by Philip Munce — November 26, 2006 @ 21:29

  3. Hey Philip,

    Same business here in France: you can’t take a bottle of water inside the stadium. The reason why it is prohibited however isn’t connected with terrorism: people fear that unhappy fans may throw their bottle on the players on the field. It actually used to happen quite often a few years ago.

    Comment by Jeremy Fain — November 27, 2006 @ 00:10

  4. It’s a sad day when a sport becomes the vehicle to promote the hidden voice of dark and sinister racist beliefs. People like these should be banned for life from all soccer grounds and stiffer penalties imposed on any individual breaking the rules of social conduct. As we see the, long over due, decline of hooliganism within the UK, it beggars belief that some small minded nit wits should go out of their way to model themselves on a past looser fad. I think that its time to impose penalties on clubs, have games played behind closed doors and remove advertising from offending clubs and hit them where it hurts, their pockets. As said, it’s a sad day when a club or a sport is hijacked by these small minded rabbles of thugs, a minority should not dictate or take away the joy of a sport from a majority, its time for action on a grand scale.
    Time for these plonkers to get a life or get out!

    Comment by Andrew Casey (Ireland) — November 28, 2006 @ 09:42

  5. Indeed Andrew. Your words are full of wisdom. When it comes to the solution you suggest (financial penalties), I’d say that would definitely be very effective. However, since such an event took place outside the stadium…Thank you Andrew, your (native) words exactly reflect what I thought on the matter.

    Comment by Jeremy Fain — November 28, 2006 @ 14:37

  6. I happened on your blog while looking for more info on the PSG incident. It’s sad when you can’t go to a sporting event for entertainment without wondering if anyone is going to attack you. I agree with Andrew Casey in that once the sponsors leave and fans boycott, the club will really feel the damage by loss of revenue. It works in the US (How well do you think Mel Gibson is going to do now after his racist rant at the cop?) Also, how about football players taking a stand by refusing to play for PSG? Maybe someone will post videos of on YouTube or something and expose these people.

    Comment by Jason (Washington D.C.) — December 8, 2006 @ 20:06

  7. Hey Jason,

    Thanks for your insight. I agreed with Andrew Casey and I agree with you: the only way to erase such behaviors from stadiums is to make a bold move. However, I believe a boycott from fans, players & sponsors, although a good idea, is a utopia: most people are not so sensitive to antisemitism. Only jewish fans, like me and many others, won’t feel like going to the stadium anymore.

    Comment by Jeremy Fain — December 8, 2006 @ 20:23

  8. I enjoyed your observations. I’m American Jew who USED to like PSG. I always respected and admired the passion of the supporters, but when racists are allowed to control the club and the club doesn’t punish those who they know are responsible because they want to sell tickets; we have a serious problem! If this attack happened to any other person (different religion, race, or even gay), I would be just as utterly disgusted. Racism will only die when people who hate it stand up to the ignorant pigs who preach intolerance.

    Pity now, PSG lost my support…guess I need to find another Ligue 1 club because I really do enjoy the players and beautiful play of the French League. Any suggestions for a club that has tolerant fans of all shades and beliefs???

    Comment by Patrick — January 11, 2007 @ 06:13

  9. I’m facing the same issue as you do Patrick. I find it hard to support another team and look at news about a different team, but I won’t support Paris Saint-Germain anymore.

    Just like you, I’m a football fan without a team to support.

    Comment by Jeremy Fain — January 11, 2007 @ 10:40

  10. Patrick, Interesting comment mate, especially from an American, no offence but never thought that you guys were much in to your “European Soccer”! More power to you! I however think that you allegiance for PSG should not be shrouded in a dark veil, more to the contrary. Let me try and explain myself. Not being Jewish myself, but having spent many wonderful years living in Israel (Tel Aviv ’02 – ’03), I subscribe to the school of thought that a sport is a sport and only that, to be played, won or lost either way it should be fun.
    Sport should not be used as a promotional vehicle for political or racial voicing of opinions but sadly it regularly is used to do so. Although I respect your pointy of view Patrick, my point is, if I were to follow your school of thought, that I let a small minority dictate my allegiance to a club or team, I am the biggest looser. Being Irish myself and an avid supporter of the Irish Rugby team, I will from time to time meet a small minority of the fan base who have some twisted belief that the English are still “the old enemy” and should me lambasted at every occasion and opportunity provided. Never, never, never! I speak my mind and put them in their place. (I am fully aware that you are located in the US and this course of action may be somewhat costly for you to replicate in the case of PSG!!) But the way that I see it is, this is my team, regardless of faith, colour or creed, it’s a sport that should be enjoyed by all walks of life and not kidnapped and held to ransom by a few misdirected and misinformed racist bigots. Stick with what you like and make your self heard! As they say, “Colossal mouth when your in a crowd but when your alone you don’t sing loud”! (Says it all for racist extremists!!!)
    PS: Remember, although football (soccer to you) is a wonderful sport, rugby is the wonder of all sports!!! Slán! Andrew

    Comment by Andrew Casey — January 30, 2007 @ 02:01

  11. PPS: As touched on earlier – we Irish (soccer this time!) need all the support we can get these days, so a disgruntled American Jew and French Jew are always more than welcome to shout for “Les Verts” in our ranks! We don’t make assumptions, we just have a great time and enjoy……………………..and loose a lot……….but what the hell! The more the merrier! A bientot les gars! Cheers Andrew

    Comment by Andrew Casey (Ireland) — January 30, 2007 @ 02:06

  12. Hey Andrew,

    I like your way, alongside with Patrick and 99% of people who leave comments on this blog, to leave insightful comments and sound, argumented view points.

    You’re making me wonder with this stance: “if I were to follow your school of thought, that I let a small minority dictate my allegiance to a club or team, I am the biggest looser.” Thank you for this.

    Comment by Jeremy Fain — January 30, 2007 @ 02:10

  13. Hi Jeremy,
    For too long in our different societies we succumb to a minority belief, not that we want to but are more or less cornered and from time to time cohered to do so. The question one needs to ask oneself is, “why should this be the case”? Being a sheep and following the flock, dictatorship of what a small body wants us to follow or pure and simple, the fear of confronting what we are afraid of but want for ourselves, yet so not know how to achieve it? I don’t have the answer Jeremy but I do voice my opinion to the bigots when and where ever I find them, they ruin my perception of a multicultural and tolerant way of life. Be it ETA, the IRA, Hamas, football hooligans, schools bullies….they all sadly hold a position and voice within our various communities but we should all remember, we have one too and they can be removed.
    Shalom!

    Comment by Andrew Casey (Ireland) — January 30, 2007 @ 02:22


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Blog at WordPress.com.